top of page

FINRA Alleges Costly Annuity Switches at Union Capital

Writer: Christopher Lufrano
Christopher Lufrano
2 hours ago
3 min read

FINRA's Department of Enforcement filed a complaint on October 5, 2026, against Gerald James O'Halloran, Francisco B. Almada, and Union Capital Company. FINRA alleges that O'Halloran and Union Capital willfully violated Regulation Best Interest (Reg BI), Exchange Act Rule 15l-1(a)(1), and violated FINRA Rules 2330(b) and 2010. FINRA also alleges that Almada and Union Capital failed to reasonably supervise O'Halloran, in violation of FINRA Rules 3110(a), 2330(c), and 2010. A complaint contains only allegations, and the respondents can contest them before a FINRA hearing panel.


According to the complaint, O'Halloran's FINRA registration dates back to August 1982. From December 2018 to June 2025, he was registered as a General Securities Representative with Union Capital, where his business centered on variable annuities sold mainly to retirees in southwest Florida. Union Capital's Form U5, dated June 27, 2025, stated that the firm let him resign because he was "[n]ot a good fit." Almada founded Union Capital in 2001 and serves as its President and CEO. FINRA alleges that he was the principal responsible for supervising variable annuity sales. Union Capital is a broker-dealer based in Tucson, Arizona, with 12 registered representatives. In December 2024, the firm settled an earlier FINRA case over its supervision of leveraged and inverse fund recommendations.


Reg BI requires a broker to act in a retail customer's best interest when making a recommendation. FINRA Rule 2330 adds specific rules for deferred variable annuities. Before recommending an exchange, a broker must weigh surrender charges, a new surrender period, lost benefits, and higher fees. Rule 2330 also requires a principal to approve each annuity transaction only after making that same judgment. For example, a broker would violate these rules by moving a client into a new annuity during the old contract's surrender period for a feature the client will never use. A supervisor would violate them by approving that switch based only on the broker's paperwork.


FINRA alleges that between May 2023 and May 2024, O'Halloran advised eight customers to swap their variable annuities for contracts from a different insurer. The switches allegedly began three months after the first insurer stopped accepting his business following a customer complaint and its own review. All eight contracts were still in their surrender periods, so the customers allegedly paid about $144,000 in surrender charges. Their combined death benefits allegedly fell by $173,365, and each new annuity carried a fresh seven-year surrender period. FINRA alleges that the main selling point was a higher annual credit to the rider's benefit base, which stops once a customer takes any withdrawal. Several customers did not plan to take withdrawals, and others were already taking them. The switches allegedly generated $180,000 in commissions, and O'Halloran received more than $162,000 of that amount. FINRA also alleges that Almada approved all eight switches despite red flags, including applications that wrongly listed five customers as under age 70.


Lufrano Law, LLC is a national investment litigation firm and has experience representing investors who have investment disputes with brokers and broker-dealers. Please contact us at (800) 627-2179 for more information if you have been the victim of investment negligence or fraud.


The content on this site reflects personal opinions and does not constitute statements of fact. No findings have been made against the firms or individuals mentioned. This blog is intended solely for educational purposes, drawing on publicly available information to provide general insights and a basic understanding of the law. It is not a substitute for legal advice.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page